Olivia’s Mommy Finds
Dr. Olivia Carter
Pediatric Specialist & Mom of Two
28 February 2025
After Months of Testing, Here’s Our Ranking of the 5 Best Teething Solutions for Babies
Here’s what We discovered:
If you’re a parent going through the teething stage, I don’t need to tell you how exhausting it is. The sleepless nights, the endless crying, the constant fussiness—nothing prepares you for just how difficult it can be.
Like many moms, I tried everything. From frozen teething rings to gels, to pain relievers—some worked for a little while, but nothing truly made teething easier for both my baby and me.
The worst part? Many traditional remedies are messy, ineffective, or filled with ingredients that I wasn’t comfortable giving my baby.
So, I went on a mission. After testing countless teething relief solutions, I finally found 5 products that actually work—and one clear winner that has been a total game-changer.
Here’s the #1 best teething solution I found, along with other alternatives worth considering.
Our Selection Criteria:
1. Effectiveness:
How well does it actually soothe teething pain?
2. Safety:
Are the ingredients 100% baby-safe and free of harmful chemicals?
3. Ease of Use:
Is it practical for parents, mess-free, and simple to apply?
4. Long-Lasting Relief:
Does it provide relief for more than just a few minutes?
Top 5 Teething Solutions of 2025:
1. GumBuddy™ Teething Relief
Price: $24.99
Overall Score
9.8/10
Overall Review:
After testing multiple products, GumBuddy™ was the clear #1 winner for providing fast, natural, and long-lasting relief—without the mess or risks of traditional remedies.
Unlike sticky teething gels or short-lived pain meds, GumBuddy™ is a roll-on teething relief that absorbs gently through the skin, calming teething pain without any harsh chemicals.
Why We Love It:
Instead of using oral medications like Tylenol or Motrin, which wear off quickly and come with dosing concerns, GumBuddy™ works externally, delivering hours of relief through soothing botanical oils.
The blend of jojoba and copaiba oleoresin provides a gentle, effective way to reduce discomfort—without the risks of numbing gels like Orajel, which contain benzocaine, a chemical that can reduce oxygen levels in a baby’s blood.
Benefits:
Fast, long-lasting relief without constant reapplying
Mess-free & easy-to-use—no sticky gels or tablets
Safe & natural ingredients—free from artificial additives
No ingestion required—absorbs externally for a gentler alternative
Cons:
Frequently out of stock
2. Orajel™ Baby Teething Gel
Price: $7.99
Rating
8.0/10
Overall Review:
Orajel has been a go-to teething solution
for years, but recent concerns about benzocaine have made many parents rethink using it. While it numbs pain, it’s temporary,
messy, and some babies dislike the taste.
Pros:
Provides fast numbing relief
Readily available in most stores
Affordable compared to other options
Cons:
Contains benzocaine, which poses risks to babies
Short-lived relief—wears off quickly
Risk of ingestion and choking hazard for some babies
3. Amber Necklace
Price: $35
Overall Score
7/10
Overall Review:
Amber necklaces claim to release natural pain-relieving properties when worn. While some parents swear by them, there’s no scientific proof they actually work. They also pose a choking hazard if not used correctly.
Pros:
Releases soothing oils
No harsh Chemicals
All natural Solution
Cons:
No scientific evidence they actually work
Potential choking hazard—not safe for all babies without supervision
No instant relief when baby is actively in pain
4. Sophie The Giraffe Teething Toy
Price: $31.99
Overall Score
7.0/10
Overall Review:
A classic teething toy made from natural rubber, Sophie La Girafe is safe, durable, and fun for babies to chew on. However, it doesn’t actively relieve pain—it simply provides a safe item to chew on.
Pros:
Durable & non-toxic
Engaging for babies
Trusted by parents worldwide
Cons:
No actual pain relief—just a toy
Expensive for what it is
Hard to clean—not dishwasher safe
5. Tylenol™ Infant Drops
Price: $10.99
Overall Score
6.5/10
Overall Review:
Tylenol™ Infant Drops are a popular choice
for parents looking for fast relief from teething pain. However, this is still a medication, meaning it requires precise dosing and wears off quickly—often leading to frequent re-dosing.
Pros:
Clinically proven pain relief
Readily available in most stores
Works quickly to soothe pain
Cons:
Wears off in a few hours, requiring multiple doses
Potential for overuse, which can be hard on a baby’s liver
Artificial additives & dyes in some versions
Conclusion
After testing dozens of teething remedies,
GumBuddy™ Teething Relief was the clear winner for parents looking for a
safe, effective, and easy-to-use
alternative to traditional teething solutions.
It’s mess-free, lasts longer than teething gels, and doesn’t require constant reapplying like frozen teethers.
If you’re looking for a natural way to soothe your baby’s teething pain fast, GumBuddy™ is the way to go.
About Olivia Carter
Pediatric Specialist & Mom
Hi! I’m Olivia Carter, a board-certified pediatric specialist and (more importantly) a mom who’s been through the struggles of teething firsthand.
After testing countless remedies, I’ve found what actually works—and I love sharing solutions that help both babies and parents through this tough stage.
I hope this list saves you the trial and error I went through. Happy teething relief!